peanut butter
Pretzel Chip Cookies
I was cleaning my baking cabinet and stumbled across a half bag of pretzels. Between Strawberry Pretzel Salad and 7 Layer Potato Chip Bars, I've gone through plenty this summer. […]
More Best Bribe Cookies
Best Bribe Cookies are regularly requested by friends who follow Sugar and Spice. It's fun to mix up Reese's Peanut Butter Cup flavors- milk, dark or white chocolate. The recipe makes […]
Babe Ruth Bars
Babe Ruth Bars are modeled on Babe Ruth candy bars. Babe Ruth Bars are delicious- chewy, crunchy and chocolatey with salty peanuts on top. Babe Ruth Bars are also no-bake, a bonus […]
Peanut Butter Scones with Reese’s Pieces
It's been a while since I've baked with Reese's Pieces. Reese's Pieces Cookies (gluten-free version also!) were a hit and peanut butter scones turned out to be even more popular. They pair […]
Peanut Butter Ice Box Pie
I'm on an ice box binge. Last summer I tested the waters with Nutella Mascarpone Ice Box Cake and recently made Creamsicle Ice Box Pie. When I saw a recipe for […]
Pirate Cupcakes
My coworker is having a birthday! She loves all things pirate and for extra fun I'm making pirate cupcakes. I made 2 different kinds- one with doubloons and another with […]
Chocolate Acorns
My nephew Grayson is 1 today! My sister is having a party with a "Woodland Creatures" theme. She asked Grayson's favorite auntie to make treats- I brought Chocolate Acorns, Smores […]
DIY Butterfinger Candy Bars
Do you ever have moments where you can't believe you didn't notice? You go through life mostly paying attention, then BAM- you realize something was right there and you missed […]
Easter Egg Truffles (again)
It's tricky writing a food blog. On one hand, you want to try new recipes to keep people coming back. On the other, you have favorite recipes you just love, […]
Peanut Butter Boiled Icing
The #1 recipe on Sugar and Spice is my grandma Eleanor's Boiled Icing. Boiled Icing is similar to fudge and makes any brownie recipe irresistible. I love boiled icing so […]